A planned concert by musician Marilyn Manson in Bern on November 22 is proceeding despite calls for its cancellation. A petition, supported by left-leaning political parties and women's organizations, demanded the show be stopped due to past allegations of sexual misconduct against the artist. However, Bern city officials and event organizers confirm the concert will take place as scheduled.
Key Takeaways
- Marilyn Manson's Bern concert on November 22 will proceed.
- A petition from left-wing groups sought cancellation over past allegations.
- Los Angeles prosecutors did not file charges after a four-year investigation.
- Bern city officials state they cannot cancel commercial events.
- Event organizers cite contractual obligations and ticket sales as barriers to cancellation.
Calls for Cancellation Over Allegations
Several women have accused Marilyn Manson, whose real name is Brian Warner, of sexual abuse, rape, and psychological and physical violence. These allegations led to a strong reaction in Bern. Various women's organizations and left-leaning political parties, including the Juso, SP, and Green Party, launched a petition to prevent the concert.
The petition, titled "No Stage for Perpetrators," specifically targeted the organizers, Bernexpo and Good News Productions AG. It argued that Manson's past work included violent and misogynistic content. Supporters of the petition believe Bern, as a hub for feminism in Switzerland, has a greater responsibility to support victims and deny platforms to alleged abusers.
Fact Check: Legal Status
- Investigation Duration: Four years
- Investigating Body: Los Angeles District Attorney's Office
- Outcome: No charges filed due to insufficient evidence
- Legal Status: Marilyn Manson has not been convicted of the alleged crimes.
Prosecutorial Decision and Legal Principles
The Los Angeles District Attorney's Office conducted a four-year investigation into the sexual assault allegations against Marilyn Manson. Following this extensive inquiry, prosecutors decided not to file charges. They stated the allegations of sexual violence could not be substantiated with enough evidence. This means Manson has not been convicted of any related crimes.
The legal principle of presumption of innocence is central to this situation. In a state governed by the rule of law, individuals are presumed innocent until proven guilty in court. This principle applies to Marilyn Manson, as no conviction has occurred.
"Banning people from stages without a verdict would be a political show trial," stated the Young Liberals of the City of Bern. "In a state governed by the rule of law, the presumption of innocence applies as long as there is no conviction. This is also the case with Marilyn Manson."
Differing Views on Concert Cancellation
The debate in Bern highlights a conflict between concerns about alleged misconduct and legal principles. The Young Liberals of the City of Bern strongly oppose the concert's cancellation. They argue that preventing performances based on unproven allegations undermines fundamental legal rights and artistic freedom.
According to the Young Liberals, the decision to hold a concert rests with the organizers. They also noted that the audience plays a role by choosing to attend or boycott an event. They stressed the importance of a diverse cultural scene that allows freedom of expression. Preventing politically unpopular performances, they argue, risks this openness.
Background: Bern's Cultural Scene
Bern is known for its active cultural scene and progressive social values. Organizations advocating for women's rights and social justice are prominent in the city. This context amplifies discussions around artistic freedom versus accountability for alleged misconduct.
City's Stance and Organizer's Response
Bern City President Marieke Kruit addressed the issue, explaining the city's limited power in the matter. She stated that the city cannot cancel the concert because it is a commercial event. Such events do not require city permits for their occurrence. The city is a minority shareholder in the exhibition grounds where the concert will take place, but this does not grant direct control over booking decisions.
However, Kruit expressed a desire for more sensitivity from the organizers. She mentioned expecting "a bit more tact" regarding the Marilyn Manson concert, given its location on city land and the city's indirect involvement. She confirmed seeking dialogue with Bernexpo on future booking processes.
Organizer's Perspective on Booking
Tom Winter, head of Bernexpo, acknowledged the criticism. He stated that Bernexpo takes the feedback seriously. He also recognized that the choice of acts at a venue sends a message. Winter indicated that Bernexpo plans to review its booking process more carefully in the future. However, he clarified that canceling the upcoming concert is financially almost impossible due to existing contracts and ticket sales.
- City's position: Cannot cancel commercial events.
- City President's concern: Expected more sensitivity from organizers.
- Bernexpo's response: Will review future booking processes but cannot cancel this concert.
The Broader Debate on Accountability and Art
The situation in Bern reflects a wider societal debate. This debate involves balancing artistic expression with accountability for personal conduct. It also touches on the legal principle of innocence until proven guilty. The Young Liberals' statement emphasized their condemnation of sexual violence. They affirmed that if allegations against Manson were confirmed by a court, they would be the first to demand strict punishment.
This incident underscores the complexities faced by cities and event organizers when balancing public sentiment, legal rights, and contractual obligations in the context of high-profile allegations. The concert is set to proceed, but the discussions surrounding it highlight ongoing concerns within the community.